Superconductivity in the $\eta$-carbide-type oxides Zr4Rh2Ox
Superconductivity in the $\eta$-carbide-type oxides Zr4Rh2Ox
Ma, KeYuan;Lago, Jorge;von Rohr, Fabian O.
We report on the synthesis and the superconductivity of Zr Rh O (x = 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 1.0). These compounds crystallize in the 4 2 x -carbide structure, which is a ﬁlled version of the complex intermetallic Ti Ni structure. We ﬁnd that in the system Zr Rh O , 2 4 2 x already a small amount (x 0.4) of oxygen addition stabilizes the -carbide structure over the more common intermetallic CuAl structure-type, in which Zr Rh crystallizes. We show that Zr Rh O and Zr Rh O are bulk superconductors with critical tempera- 2 4 2 0.7 4 2 tures of T 2.8 K and 4.7 K in the resistivity, respectively. Our analysis of the superconducting properties reveal both compounds to be strongly type-II superconductors with critical ﬁelds up to H (0) 8.8 mT and H (0) 6.08 T. Our results support that 0 c1 0 c2 the -carbides are a versatile family of compounds for the investigation of the interplay of interstitial doping on physical properties, especially for superconductivity. Keywords: oxides, carbides, -carbides, superconductivity, intermetallics, Ti Ni-structure, CuAl -structure 2 2 1. Introduction three inequivalent Wycko 16d, 32e, and 48f positions. The large unit cell of Ti Ni consists of eight cubic sub-cells having A promising approach for superconductivity has been the ex- two alternating patterns, and the interstitial positions between ploration of layered or cage structured compounds with inter- these sub-cells are unoccupied (see, e.g., reference ). The layer or void positions that can be occupied with additive ele- -carbide structure can be understood as a ﬁlled version of the ments as electron dopants . Most prominently, superconduc- Ti Ni structure, where the light nonmetallic atoms occupy the tivity with a critical temperature of T 4 K was for example 16c Wycko position. Therefore, the transition from the Ti Ni discovered in layered Cu TiSe via the incorporation of copper x 2 structure to the -carbide structure corresponds to a ﬁlling of the between the TiSe layers . In these materials, the addition of cage structured material. This results in a system with tunable copper suppresses a charge-density wave transition and a new crystal and composition chemistry, which create opportunities superconducting state emerges. An example of a cage struc- to modify the properties of these materials by doping interstitial tured material in which superconductivity is enhanced, is the atoms on this 16c position. compound Nb Ir O with a critical temperature of T 10.5 K 5 3 c About 120 compounds are known that crystallize in the . In this material oxygen acts as a dopant into the confa- -carbide-type structure (see, e.g. reference ). Only few cial trigonal antiprismatic channels of the Mn Si -type struc- 5 3 of these compounds have been investigated for their physi- ture. Filling these crystallographic spaces with foreign oxygen cal properties. Recently, a wide variety of magnetic order- atoms serves to modify the band topology and increase the su- ings have been reported in this structure type, such as mag- perconducting transition temperature. netic frustration, ferromagnetism, and strong magnetic corre- The here investigated class of compounds crystallize in the lations [13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18]. Known -carbide-type oxides so-called -carbide structure, which is named after its ﬁrst rep- are T M O with T (16d, 32e) = Mn, Fe, Co, Ni and M = Mo, W, 3 3 resentatives Fe W C and Fe W C [4, 5]. Compounds with 3 3 4 2 Zr T O with T (16d, 32e) = V, Cr, Mn, and M T O with T = Fe, 3 3 4 2 this structure are commonly also referred to as E9 phases Ni, and Re M = Zr, Nb, and Ta [19, 20, 21, 22]. . -carbides are hard and brittle intermetallic materials A few compounds with the -carbide-type structure were re- that exist for a range of compositions and non-stoichiometries ported to be superconductors with critical temperatures up to [7, 8, 9, 10]. These compounds crystallize in the cubic space ¯ T 9 K [22, 23]. Earlier reports on the superconductivity in group Fd3m and they commonly form for the compositions these materials, however, lack generally a detailed characteriza- A B X and A B X with A and B being transition metals, 3 3 1 4 2 1 tion of the chemical structure and purity, as well as the physical and X being carbon, nitrogen, or oxygen . They consist of properties in both the superconducting and the normal state. a three dimensional metal network on a pyrochlore-type lattice nested by tetrahedrons. This structural feature is commonly re- Here, we report on the superconductivity in the carbides ferred to as stella quadrangula. These super-tetrahedra share Zr Rh O and Zr Rh O with a maximal critical temperature 4 2 0.7 4 2 vertices to form an inﬁnite diamondoid-like network [6, 10, 11]. T 4.7 K. We ﬁnd that these are bulk superconductor, with The prototypical Ti Ni structure has a large face-centered-cubic a variable critical temperature depending on the oxygen con- (fcc) unit cell that contains 96 metallic atoms occupying the tent. Temperature-dependent magnetic susceptibility, electrical Preprint submitted to Elsevier May 21, 2019 arXiv:1905.07402v1 [cond-mat.supr-con] 17 May 2019 30000 (a) Zr Rh I4/mcm (a) Zr Zr Rh O 4 2 0.7 η−carbide-type oxide Zr Rh Mo K T = 298 K a ≈ 12.41 Å Rh a b (b) Ti Ni Fd3mS 2 Ti Ti Ni (b) Zr Rh O 4 2 a Ni η−carbide-type oxide a 20000 Mo K T = 298 K 15000 a ≈ 12.38 Å (c) Zr Rh O Fd3mZ 4 2 Zr Zr Oxygen posi�on 16c Rh Rh a 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 2Θ (°) Figure 1: Crystal structures of (a) Zr Rh, (b) Ti Ni, and Zr Rh O. The struc- 2 2 4 2 ture of Zr Rh O clearly diers from the structure of the intermetallic phase 4 2 Figure 2: PXRD pattern (red points) at ambient temperature with LeBail ﬁts Zr Rh, it can be interpreted as a ﬁlled version of the Ti Ni structure. 2 2 (black line) of the samples with the nominal compositions (a) Zr Rh O and 4 2 0.7 (b) Zr Rh O. The vertical dark green lines show the theoretical Bragg peak po- 4 2 sitions of the -carbide-type phase. For Zr Rh O the broad impurity refelctions 4 2 transport and speciﬁc heat measurements were used to char- of Zr Rh are marked with a star. acterize the superconductors. Our ﬁndings show that earlier re- ports of a critical temperature of T 12 K in the system Zr-Rh- The crystal structure and phase purity of the samples were in- O cannot be attribute to compounds with the -carbide structure vestigated by powder x-ray diraction (PXRD) measurements (see reference ). Our results support that the -carbides are on a STOE STADIP diractometer with Mo K radiation a versatile family of compounds for the investigation of the in- ( = 0.70930 Å). The PXRD patterns were collected in the 2 terplay of interstitial doping on physical properties, especially range of 5-50 with a scan rate of 0.25 /min. LeBail ﬁts were for superconductivity. performed using the FULLPROF program package. The temperature- and ﬁeld-dependent magnetization mea- surements were performed using a Quantum Design magnetic 2. Experimental properties measurement system (MPMSXL) with a 7 T magnet equipped with a reciprocating sample option (RSO). The mea- Polycrystalline samples of Zr Rh O with x = 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 4 2 x sured plate like samples were placed in parallel to the external 0.7, and 1.0 were prepared from mixtures of zirconium sponge magnetic ﬁeld to minimize demagnetization eects. Speciﬁc (99.5%, Alfa Aesar), zirconium (IV) oxide (ZrO ) powder heat capacity and resistivity measurements were performed (99.995%, Sigma-Aldrich) and rhodium powder (99.8%, Strem with a Quantum Design physical property measurement system Chemicals, Inc.). Stoichiometric mixture of the starting mate- (PPMS) with a 9 T magnet. The standard four-probe technique rials were pressed into pellets. These were melted in an arc fur- was employed to measure the electrical resistivity with an ex- nace in a puriﬁed argon atmosphere on a water-cooled copper citation current of I = 1.5 mA. In the resistivity measurement, plate. gold wires were connected to the sample with silver paint. The samples were molten 10 times in order to assure the op- timal homogeneity of the products, which have high melting points. Subsequently, the solidiﬁed melt was carefully ground 3. Results and Discussion to a ﬁne powder and pressed into a pellet. The pellet was sealed in a quartz tube with 1/3 atm argon and heated in a furnace for Crystal Structure. In ﬁgure 1(a)-(c), we show a schematic 10 days. The samples with an oxygen content with less than view of the crystal structures of Zr Rh, Ti Ni, and the -carbide 2 2 x 0.7 were annealed at 1000 C, whereas samples with an Zr Rh O. The compound Zr Rh crystallizes in the common bi- 4 2 2 oxygen content of more than x > 0.7 were annealed at 800 C. nary intermetallic structure-type CuAl , generated by square- Intensity (arb. units) Intensity (arb. units) triangle nets of atoms, with the body-centered tetragonal space of rocksalt-type ZrRh and the starting materials for all our at- group I4=mcm. The compound Ti Ni crystallizes in its own tempts on this stoichiometry. cubic structure-type with space group Fd3m. The coordina- Magnetic Properties. In ﬁgure 3(a), we show the tion number of all atoms in this structure-type is 12, whereas temperature-dependent magnetization of Zr Rh O and 4 2 0.7 the nickel atoms on the Wycko position 32e arrange on reg- Zr Rh O measured in zero-ﬁeld cooled (ZFC) and ﬁeld-cooled 4 2 ular tetrahedra, while the titanium atoms on the Wycko po- (FC) mode in an external magnetic ﬁeld of H = 2 mT. Both sition 48f form regular octahedra. The close relationship be- samples are found to have a diamagnetic shielding fractions tween the Ti Ni structure, the Cr C , and the -carbide struc- corresponding to a bulk superconductor, i.e. > 1. Subse- 2 23 6 ture, which has the same metal matrix organization as Ti Ni, is quently, the magnetization curves are normalized by plotting depicted in ﬁgure 1(b)&(c). An important factor of the Ti Ni the data as M(T )=M(1.75 K) for better comparability. We ﬁnd and the Cr C structure, respectively, is the ability to dissolve a superconducting transition temperature of T 2.6 K, and 23 6 c light nonmetallic atoms such as carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, or 4.3 K, in the magnetization for Zr Rh O and Zr Rh O, re- 4 2 0.7 4 2 hydrogen in the interstitial positions. The incorporated inter- spectively. stitial atoms can aect the properties of the compounds drasti- The temperature-dependent magnetization (M(T )/H) in cally. The ideal fully stoichiometric -carbide Zr Rh O has a zero-ﬁeld cooled (ZFC) mode in an external magnetic ﬁeld 4 2 cubic structure adopting the space group Fd3m, with four dis- of H = 2 mT of the samples with x = 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, tinct atoms sites with the Wycko positions 48f, 32e, 16d, and and 1.0 between T = 1.75 K to 8 K are shown in the Sup- 16c. The zirconium atoms occupy the 16d site and the rhodium plemental Information. They all show single superconducting atoms are in the 32e position forming a network of tetrahedra, transitions with critical temperatures between T 4.3 K and while zirconium atoms in the 48f site form a network of octa- 2.5 K, with the highest T observed for the sample Zr Rh O. c 4 2 hedra in which every second one is slightly distorted. These oc- All samples are bulk superconductors with diamagnetic shield- tahedra are connected by sharing faces. The oxygen atoms ﬁll ing fraction larger than 1. In the Supplemental Information up the interstitial position 16c and play a crucial role in stabi- the temperature-dependent magnetization between T = 10 K lizing the ternary -carbide structure, rather than the for Zr Rh to 300 K for Zr Rh O in an external ﬁeld of H = 0.1 T is 2 4 2 0 reported intermetallic CuAl -type structure. shown. We ﬁnd, Zr Rh O to be a Pauli paramagnetic metal 2 4 2 The room-temperature PXRD pattern and the corresponding in the normal state, with little temperature-dependence of the LeBail ﬁts of polycrystalline samples of the nominal composi- magnetization. tions Zr Rh O and Zr Rh O are shown in ﬁgure 2. The re- In ﬁgure 3(b), we show the ZFC ﬁeld-dependent magnetiza- 4 2 4 2 0.7 sults for x = 0.4, 0.5, and 0.6 are shown in the Supplemental In- tion m(H) in ﬁelds between H = 0 to 25 mT for temperatures formation. All PXRD pattern can be indexed with the -carbide between T = 1.75 to 4 K (in 0.25 K steps). It is well-known to structure (green vertical tick marks) as the main phase and a be challenging to extract precise values for the lower critical CuAl -type structure corresponding to Zr Rh as a minor impu- ﬁeld H from m(H) measurements, especially for polycrys- 2 2 c1 rity phase. Interestingly, already small oxygen contents, e.g. talline samples. As a criterion, we have here used the identi- for Zr Rh O , stabilize the -carbide-type structure, which is ﬁcation of H as the magnetic ﬁeld where m(H) ﬁrst deviates 4 2 0.4 c1 of considerably higher complexity than the CuAl -type struc- from linearity. The extracted H values are plotted in the in- 2 c1 ture. set of ﬁgure 3(b). A reasonable estimate for H (0) can then be c1 Furthermore, it is noteworthy that no zirconium oxide, es- obtained by using the following empirical formula  pecially no Zr(IV) oxide ZrO , was observed as an impurity for any of the samples. The reﬂections from Zr Rh decrease H (T ) = H (0)[1 (T=T ) ]: (1) 2 c1 c1 c for increasing oxygen contents of the nominal compositions. With this approximation, we obtain a lower critical ﬁeld of Compared with other samples, the stoichiometry of Zr Rh O 4 2 0.7 H (0) 8.8 mT. This value is in good agreement with similar 0 c1 displays the highest phase purity, with almost no detectable superconducting materials. impurity peaks. We observe the lattice parameter a of the Electrical Transport. The temperature-dependent electri- -carbide-type phase to change only slightly for the dierent cal resistivity (T ) in zero-ﬁeld of polycrystalline samples of samples. The slight decrease of the cell parameter a might be Zr Rh O and Zr Rh O are presented in ﬁgure 4(a)&(b). 4 2 0.7 4 2 associated to a slight decreasing of the interstitial voids due The room temperature resistivities of the two compounds are to enhanced chemical bonding by the addition of the oxygen (300K) = 0.11 m cm and 0.23 m cm, respectively. With atoms. A similar behavior was observed in the ﬁlled Mn Si - 5 3 decreasing temperature, the resistivity decreases only slightly type oxides Nb Ir O and Zr Pt O [1, 24]. The cell parame- 5 3 5 3 with a nearly linear temperature dependence of ter of the LeBail ﬁts, the and the R -values of the ﬁts exp (both measures for the validity of the structural model) with = + T: (2) a model consisting of the two phases Zr Rh and an -carbide are summarized in table 1. Attempts to prepare -carbides with Here, is the residual resistivity, revealing a metallic behav- a stoichiometry of A B X , where the 48f Wycko position ior with a low room temperature resistivity value in the normal 3 3 1 is occupied by the transition metal B, i.e. rhodium, did not state of = 0.10 m cm for Zr Rh O , and = 0.14 m cm 0 4 2 0.7 0 yield any -carbide-type structures for all tested compositions for Zr Rh O, respectively. The residual resistivity ratio (RRR) 4 2 and synthesis temperatures. Instead we have obtained mixtures value for Zr Rh O is RRR = (300 K)/(5 K) 1.08, and 4 2 0.7 3 Nominal Compositions Zr Rh O Zr Rh O Zr Rh O Zr Rh O Zr Rh O 4 2 0.4 4 2 0.5 4 2 0.6 4 2 0.7 4 2 cell parameter a [Å] 12.41270(6) 12.40608(5) 12.40143(3) 12.41014 (3) 12.38112 (8) Quality of the LeBail ﬁt 7.61 5.55 2.85 3.74 9.75 Quality of the LeBail ﬁt R 8.99 8.94 10.54 7.89 7.91 exp Table 1: Cell parameters a of the prepared samples with the nominal compositions Zr Rh O with x = 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, and 1.0, and the quality of the reﬁnements 4 2 x of the performed LeBail ﬁts with a model consisting of the two phases Zr Rh and an -carbide. Zr Rh O is RRR = (300 K)/(5 K) 1.62. The RRR values 4 2 and the absolute values of resistivity indicating that Zr Rh O is 4 2 slightly more metallic than Zr Rh O . The values are, how- 4 2 0.7 ever, similar for both. They correspond to poor metals and are especially for intermetallics with substantial covalent bonding and for metallic oxides (see, e.g., references [26, 27]). Both compounds show distinct transitions to a superconduct- (a) 0.0 FC ing state in the resistivity at critical temperatures of T = 2.8 K for Zr Rh O and T = 4.7 K for Zr Rh O, respectively. These 4 2 0.7 c 4 2 -0.2 values are slightly higher, and therefore in good agreement with the values obtained from the magnetization measurements. -0.4 In the inset of ﬁgures 4(a)&(b), the normalized resistivities (T )/(6 K) in external magnetic ﬁelds between H = 0 T to -0.6 5 T and 7 T, restrictively, are shown. As expected for type-II Zr Rh O 4 2 0.7 superconductors, the critical temperature decreases steadily as -0.8 Zr Rh O 4 2 the applied magnetic ﬁeld increases for both samples. µ H = 2 mT In order to determine the upper critical ﬁelds H (0) the com- c2 ZFC -1.0 monly used 50% criterion was applied, which corresponds to 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 the midpoints of resistances (see, e.g. references [28, 29, 30]). Temperature (K) The obtained values are plotted in ﬁgure 4(c). The extrapo- (b) 4 K lated slopes near T are dH /dT = -2.51(6) T/K for Zr Rh O , c c2 4 2 0.7 and dH /dT = -1.95(2) T/K for Zr Rh O. From these slopes, c2 4 2 we can make a conservative evaluation of the upper critical -1 ﬁelds at zero temperature H (0) using the Werthamer-Helfand- c2 Hohenberg (WHH) approximation in the dirty limit, according to : -2 µ H (0) ≈ 8.8 mT 0 c1 7.5 T = 1.75 K dH c2 WHH H (0) = 0:693 T : (3) 5.0 c c2 dT -3 T =T 2.5 ﬁt to eq. (1) The resulting upper critical ﬁelds are H (0) 4.87 T for Zr Rh O 0 c2 0 2 4 4 2 Temperature (K) Zr Rh O , and H (0) 6.35 T for Zr Rh O, respectively. -4 4 2 0.7 0 c2 4 2 0 100 200 Both upper critical ﬁelds are lower than, and therefore in agree- B (G) ment with the Pauli paramagnetic limit, where H = 0 Pauli 1:85 T = 5.18 T for Zr Rh O , and H = 8.70 T for Figure 3: (a) ZFC and FC magnetization of Zr Rh O and Zr Rh O in an 4 2 0.7 4 2 c 4 2 0.7 0 Pauli external ﬁeld of H = 2 mT between T = 1.75 K to 8 K. In the inset, the Zr Rh O. 4 2 temperature-dependent magnetization between T = 10 K to 300 K in an exter- The above determined critical ﬁelds H (0) and H (0) can c1 c2 nal ﬁeld of H = 1 T is shown. (b) Field-dependent magnetization of Zr Rh O 0 4 2 be used to calculate several other superconducting parameters. between T = 1.75 K to 4 K in 0.25 K steps in low ﬁelds H < 25 mT in or- der to determine the lower critical ﬁeld H . The inset shows the temperature According to Ginzburg-Landau theory, the upper critical ﬁeld at c1 dependence of the lower critical ﬁeld H of Zr Rh O. c1 4 2 T = 0 K, H (0), can be used to estimate the coherence length c2 (0) according to the expression H (0) = : (4) 0 c2 2 (0) Here, = h=(2e) 2:0678 10 Wb is the magnetic ﬂux quantum. The resulting coherence lengths for Zr Rh O is 4 2 0.7 -M(T)/M(1.75 K) m (emu) µ H (T) (mT) 0 c1 -2.51(6) T/K -1.95(2) T/K Parameters Zr Rh O Zr Rh O 4 2 0.7 4 2 T [K] 2.6 4.3 c;magnetization T [K] 2.8 4.7 c;resistivity (a) 0.12 T [K] 2.7 4.1 Zr Rh O c;speciﬁcheat 4 2 0.7 0.10 (300K) [m cm] 0.11 0.23 RRR 1.08 1.62 0.08 5 T 1.0 H (0) [mT] - 8.8 c1 0 T 0.06 0.8 H (0) [T] 4.89 6.08 c2 0.6 0.04 1 4 [mJ mol K ] 1.43 2.01 0.4 1 2 0.2 0.02 [mJ mol K ] 14.5 17.9 0.0 [K] 209 189 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 0.00 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 (0) [Å] 83 72 Temperature (K) (0) [Å] - 3199 (b) Zr Rh O 4 2 0.20 H [mT] - 101 0 c C=
T 2.25 1.74 0.15 7 T 1.0 0.60 0.73 el ph 0.8 (0) [meV] 0.47 0.64 0.10 0 T 0.6 0.4 Table 2: Summary of the superconducting and normal state parameters of 0.05 Zr Rh O and Zr Rh O. 4 2 0.7 4 2 0.2 0.0 2 3 4 5 6 0.00 (0) = 82 Å, and (0) = 73 Å for Zr Rh O, respectively. 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 4 2 Temperature (K) (c) The here obtained values clearly indicate that these Zr Rh O 4 2 0.7 -carbide-type oxides must be strongly type-II supercon- Zr Rh O 4 2 ductors with a Ginzburg-Landau parameter of the order of = = 44 for Zr Rh O. Type-II superconductors need 4 2 to have a value for > 1= 2. Ginzburg-Landau parameter is estimated from the above obtained values for H (0) and (0) c1 by using the relations : H = ln ; (5) 0 c1 With this relations we ﬁnd a value of 3199Å for Zr Rh O. Combining the results of H (0), H (0) and the 4 2 c1 c2 0 1 2 3 4 5 Temperature (K) thermodynamic critical ﬁeld H can be estimated according to Figure 4: (a)&(b) Temperature-dependent resistivities in zero ﬁeld of H H = H ln( ): (6) c1 c2 c Zr Rh O and Zr Rh O between T = 300 K to 1.8 K, respectively. The 4 2 0.7 4 2 insets show the normalized resistivities (T )=(6K) in the vicinity of the super- This calculation yields H 101 mT for Zr Rh O. 0 c 4 2 conducting transition and in external ﬁelds between B = 0 T to 7 T in 0.5 T Speciﬁc Heat. In ﬁgure 5 the temperature-dependent spe- steps. (c) Upper critical ﬁelds of Zr Rh O and Zr Rh O determined by the 4 2 0.7 4 2 ciﬁc heat capacities C(T ) of Zr Rh O and Zr Rh O are de- 4 2 0.7 4 2 50% criterion from the data shown in the insets of (a)&(b). picted in the vicinity of the superconducting transition. The data is plotted in a C=T vs. T representation. The normal-state contribution constitutes above the critical temperature T of an electronic (C ) and a phononic (C ) contribution, and can el phonon be ﬁtted according to the expression: ρ (mΩ cm) ρ (mΩ cm) µ H (T) 0 c2 ρ(T) / ρ(6 K) ρ(T) / ρ(6 K) (a) Zr Rh O C + C C(T ) 4 2 0.7 el phonon = =
+ T (7) 100 T T where
is the electronic speciﬁc heat coecient and is the coecient of the lattice contribution. The resulting values for 1 4 1 4 are 1.43 mJ mol K for Zr Rh O and 2.01 mol K 4 2 0.7 for Zr Rh O, respectively. The corresponding values for 4 2 1 2 are found to be 14.5 mJ mol K for Zr Rh O and 4 2 0.7 1 2 40 2 ...... C/T = γ + βT 17.9 mJ mol K for Zr Rh O. The Debye temperature 4 2 D γ =14.5 mJ/mol K can be calculated according the following relation: β =1.43 mJ/mol K 4 3 (b) = nR (8) Zr Rh O 4 2 where R is the ideal gas constant and n is the number of atoms per formula unit. The resulting Debye temperatures are calcu- lated to be 209 K for Zr Rh O , and 189 K for D 4 2 0.7 D Zr Rh O. The electronic speciﬁc heat (C ) is obtained by sub- 4 2 el tracting the normal state phononic contribution C from the phonon total speciﬁc heat. ...... 2 C/T = γ + βT The critical temperatures obtained in the speciﬁc heat mea- 40 2 γ =17.9 mJ/mol K surements are T 2.7 K for Zr Rh O and 4.1 K for Zr Rh O β =2.01 mJ/mol K c 4 2 0.7 4 2 using an equal-area entropy construction method. These val- 20 ues are in good agreement with the critical temperatures ob- 2 3 4 5 6 7 Temperature (K) tained from resistivity and magnetization measurements. The normalized speciﬁc heat jump, C=
T is found to be 2.25 for Figure 5: Temperature-dependent speciﬁc heat capacities C(T ) of (a) Zr Rh O and 1.74 for Zr Rh O. Both values are larger than 4 2 0.7 4 2 Zr Rh O and (b) Zr Rh O between T = 2 K to 7 K. The data is plotted in 4 2 0.7 4 2 the weak coupling BSC limit of 1.43, verifying the bulk nature a C=T vs. T representation. The dotted line corresponds to a ﬁt of the normal state speciﬁc heat capacities, according to equation 7. of the superconductivity in both compounds. The electron-phonon coupling constant can be esti- el ph mated using the McMillan formula. This formula is based on table 2. the phonon spectrum of niobium [33, 34]. This approximation is valid for < 1:25 : el ph 1:04 + ln 1:45T = (9) el ph 4. Conclusion (1 0:62 )ln 1:04 1:45T In summary, we have described the successful synthesis of The parameter is the eective Coulomb repulsion, which the -carbides with the nominal compositions Zr Rh O with 4 2 x arises from Coulomb-coupling propagating much more rapidly x = 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, and 1.0. We ﬁnd that already a small than phonon-coupling. For the estimation of the electron- addition of oxygen changes the crystal structure from the very phonon coupling, we are using the common approximation common intermetallic CuAl -type to the -carbide-type struc- of = 0.13. This value is an average value, which is valid ture, which corresponds to a ﬁlled version of the Ti Ni struc- for many intermetallic superconductors (see, e.g., reference ture. Nearly phase-pure samples, with the minor impurity phase [30, 32]). We obtain electron-phonon coupling constants Zr Rh, were obtained for all nominal compositions. of 0.60 for Zr Rh O and 0.73 for Zr Rh O, re- el ph 4 2 0.7 4 2 The compounds Zr Rh O and Zr Rh O compounds were 4 2 0.7 4 2 spectively. These values suggest that both compounds are found to be bulk superconductors with critical temperatures weak-coupling superconductor. of T 2.8 K and 4.7 K in the resistivity, respectively. We have characterized the properties of Zr Rh O and Zr Rh O 4 2 0.7 4 2 From the electronic low temperature speciﬁc heat data, we in the normal and the superconducting states by magnetization, have estimated the value of the superconducting gap (0) of electrical transport, and speciﬁc heat capacity measurements. the two compounds, according to Both, compounds display a well developed discontinuity in the speciﬁc heat of C=
T 2.25 for Zr Rh O and 1.74 for c 4 2 0.7 C = a exp( (0)=k T ): (10) el B c Zr Rh O, respectively, and a large diamagnetic shielding frac- 4 2 We obtain calculated superconducting gaps of tion ( > 1), which conﬁrm the the bulk nature of super- (0) 0.47 meV for Zr Rh O and 0.64 meV for Zr Rh O, conductivity in these materials. We ﬁnd these -carbide-type 4 2 0.7 4 2 respectively. All superconducting parameters that we have oxides to be strong type-II superconductors with upper critical obtained here for Zr Rh O and Zr Rh O are summarized in ﬁelds H close to the Pauli paramagnetic limit. 4 2 0.7 4 2 0 c2 2 2 C/T (mJ/mol K ) C/T (mJ/mol K ) Our ﬁndings indicate that earlier reports of a critical temper-  N.R. Werthamer, E. Helfand, and P.C. Hohenberg, Physical Review 147 (1966) 295. ature of T 12 K in the system Zr-Rh-O cannot be attribute  T. Klimczuk, C.H. Wang, K. Gofryk, F. Ronning, J. Winterlik, G.H. to the -carbide structure (for the here investigated stoichiome- Fecher, J.-C. Griveau, E. Colineau, C. Felser, J.D. Thompson, D.J. Sa- tries). But, it is likely that these critical temperatures are rather farik, R.J. Cava, Phys. Rev. B 85 (2012) 174505.  W.L. McMillan, Phys. Rev. 167 (1968) 331. related to the CuAl -type Zr Rh alloys (see, e.g., reference 2 2 – x x  R.C. Dynes, Solid State Commun. 10 (1972) 615. ). We ﬁnd the -carbides to be a versatile family of com-  P.B. Allen, R.C. Dynes, Phys. Rev. B 12 (1975) 3. pounds for the investigation of the interplay of interstitial dop-  S.L. McCarthy, Journal of Low Temperature Physics 4 (1971) 485. ing on physical properties, especially for superconductivity. Acknowledgments This work was supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation under Grant No. PZ00P2 174015. References  H. Hosono, S.-W. Kim, S. Matsuishi, S. Tanaka, A. Miyake, T. Ka- gayama, K. Shimizu, Phil.Trans. R. Soc. A373 (2015) 20140450.  E. Morosan, H. W. Zandbergen, B. S. Dennis, J. W. G. Bos, Y. Onose, T. Klimczuk, A. P. Ramirez, N. P. Ong, R. J. Cava, Nature Physics 2 (2006)  Y. Zhang, B. Wang, Z. Xiao, Y. Lu, T. Kamiya, Y. Uwatoko, H. Kageyama, H. Hosono, npj Quantum Materials 2 (2017) 45.  V. Adelskold, ¨ A. Sunderlin, A. Westgren, Z. anorg. Chem. 212 (1933)  A. Westgren, G. Phragmen, Trans. Amer. Soc. Steel Treat. 13 (1928) 539.  H. Nyman, S. Andersson, M. O’Keee, J. Solid State Chem. 26 (1978)  L.E. Toth, Transition Metal Carbides and Nitrides, Refractory Materials, Academic Press, New York (1971).  A.C. Fraker, H.H. Stadelmaier, Trans. Metal. AIME 245 (1969) 847.  S.M. Hunter, D. Mckay, R.I. Smith, J.S.J. Hargreaves, D.H. Gregory, Chem. Mater., 22 (2010), p. 2898.  M. Souissi, H.F. Sluiter, T. Matsunaga, M. Tabuchi, M.J. Mills, Ryoji Sahara Scientiﬁc Reports 8 (2018) 7279.  L.A. Sviridov, P.D. Battle, F. Grandjean, G.J. Long, T.J. Prior, Inorg. Chem. 49 (2010) 1133.  M. Hellebrandt, Crystallography Reviews 10 (2004) 17.  T. Waki, S. Terazawa, Y. Umemoto, Y. Tabata, Y. Murase, M. Kato, K. Hirota, H Nakamura, Journal of Physics: Conference Series 344 (2012)  T. Waki, S. Terazawa, Y. Tabata, F. Oba, C. Michioka, K. Yoshimura, S. Ikeda, H.Kobayashi, K. Ohoyama, H. Nakamura, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 79 (2010) 043701.  T. Waki, S. Terazawa, Y. Tabata, Y. Murase, M. Kato, K. Hirota, S. Ikeda, H.Kobayashi, K. Sato, K. Kindo, H. Nakamura, J. Alloys Comp. 509 (2011) 9451.  R.N. Panda, N.S. Gajbhiye, J. Alloys Comp. 256 (1997) 102.  S.K. Jackson, R.C. Layland, H.-C. zur Loye, J. Alloys Comp. 291 (1999)  T.J. Prior, P.D. Battle, J. Mater. Chem. 14 (2004) 3001.  N. Schonberg, Acta Chem. Scand. 8 (1954) 932.  H. Holleck and F. Thummler, J. Nucl. mater. 23 (1967) 88.  H. Holleck and F. Thummler, Mh. Chemie 112 (1967) 133.  B. T. Matthias et al., Rev. Mod. Phys. 35 (1963) 1.  H.C. Ku and D.C. Johnson, Chinese Journal of Physics 22 (1984) 59.  S. Hamamoto and J. Kitagawa, Mater. Res. Express 5 (2018) 106001.  E. H. Brandt, Phys. Rev. B 68 (2003) 054506.  F.O. von Rohr, H. Luo, N. Ni, M. Worle, ¨ and R. J. Cava, Phys. Rev. B 89 (2014) 224504.  F.O. von Rohr, A. Ryser, H. Ji, K. Stolze, J. Tao, J.J. Frick, G.R. Patzke, R.J. Cava, Chem. Eur. J. 25 (2019) 2082.  T.P. Orlando, E.J. McNi Jr, S. Foner, M. R. Beasley, Phys. Rev. B 19 (1979) 4545.  F. von Rohr, R. Nesper, A. Schilling, Phys. Rev. B 89 (2014) 094505.  F.O. von Rohr, M. Winiarski, J. Tao, T. Klimczuk, R.J. Cava, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 113 (2016) E7144.
http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.pngCondensed MatterarXiv (Cornell University)http://www.deepdyve.com/lp/arxiv-cornell-university/superconductivity-in-the-eta-carbide-type-oxides-zr4rh2ox-3vT00bEGRw
Superconductivity in the $\eta$-carbide-type oxides Zr4Rh2Ox